Who's the Best Sherlock Holmes? Five Distinct Takes on the Great Detective, Ranked

Sherlock Holmes has been interpreted in many forms throughout the years. The vast array of adaptations highlights the character's versatility and appeal. According to Guinness, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's creation remains the most portrayed literary character in film and TV. By 2012, there were 254 distinct on-screen portrayals, with over 75 actors interpreting the role since silent film's inception.

The character's defining traits inspire varied interpretations. Different adaptations present Holmes with diverse ages, races, geographic backgrounds, and historical settings. Some versions dive into Sherlock's sexuality, while others tackle themes of addiction. Meta interpretations explore the mythology surrounding Holmes, sometimes treating it as absurd. Ultimately, these diverse representations invite questions about legacy and essence, a challenge for any of the iterations discussed below.

5. Robert Downey Jr. (Sherlock Holmes, 2009; Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows, 2011)

Robert Downey Jr.'s blend of Hollywood star power and Holmes' timeless appeal rejuvenated the character. These films introduced a more physical rendition of Sherlock, evident from the start with parkour sequences. This emphasis aligns with Conan Doyle's original depiction; in A Study in Scarlet, Watson describes Holmes as an expert boxe, swordsman, and singlestick player.

Downey Jr.'s interpretation strays significantly from the classical gentleman stereotype. Instead, he embraces a rougher side that elevates authenticity. This evolution contrasts sharply with earlier adaptations, as his brashness resonates well with the vibrant mysteries depicted in these films.

4. Jonny Lee Miller (Elementary, 2012–2019)

During the 2010s, two contemporary Sherlock series aired simultaneously. Many overlook Jonny Lee Miller's unique spin while meeting the demanding narratives of CBS thriller dramas. Miller's portrayal stretched across seven seasons, totaling 154 episodes—a notable accomplishment given the competition.

His iteration centers on Sherlock's recovery from addiction, beginning with a fresh-out-of-rehab character. Dr. Watson serves as his sober companion, bringing warmth to her vital role. In this adaptation, Holmes embodies vulnerability while retaining his essential brilliance, making him relatable.

3. Basil Rathbone (The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes and more, 1939-1946)

Basil Rathbone cemented his legacy as the quintessential Sherlock Holmes for several generations. Over seven years, Rathbone graced 14 films, mostly under 20th Century Fox and Universal Pictures. His portrayal emphasizes Holmes as a calm solver, often overshadowing individual character traits.

Interestingly, Rathbone himself struggled with engaging sympathy for Holmes. He acknowledged this mental distance in a quote referencing Holmes’ complex personality, stating that cohesion often made the character unlovable. Despite this inner conflict, his steady persona remains an iconic presence in Holmes' cinematic history.

2. Jeremy Brett (Sherlock Holmes, 1984–1994)

Among traditional adaptations, Jeremy Brett stands out as the paramount performer. Featuring in a multitude of Granada Television mysteries, Brett combined intellectual charisma with incisive humor. What sets him apart is a palpable sense of humanity etched onto the character.

Over his tenure, he inhabited scenes with remarkable authenticity, balancing emotional depth with intellect. His portrayals aligned closely with Conan Doyle’s writings, leaving a lasting impression as one of the most beloved representations of Sherlock Holmes.

1. Benedict Cumberbatch (Sherlock, 2010–2017)

Benedict Cumberbatch's interpretation of Sherlock remains exceptional, seamlessly bridging the traditional with modernity. This version presents Holmes without antiquated period customs typically linked to the character. The New Year’s Day 2016 special, "The Abominable Bride," further showcases this range, displaying fluidity between contexts.

While it's premature to assess the long-term impact of Sherlock, Cumberbatch's commitment revitalized the character. He retains authenticity amid modern concerns. By exploring Sherlock's complexity, he reveals deep humanity beneath surface-level eccentricities. This nuanced characterization keeps the legend alive, ensuring its relevance through diverse depictions.

This fascinating exploration of the character’s outward bravado and inner vulnerabilities cements Sherlock Holmes as an enduring figure in our cultural narrative.

Earlier, SSP told about all Harry Potter movies: ranked from worst to best.